Save For Later!

Make your next party a hit with a baked potato bar using this guide to Baked Potato Bar Toppings. You’ll find everything you need to create a delicious baked potato food bar, including tips for setup, keeping food warm, recipe ideas for toppings, and fun international loaded baked potato themes.

I’m going to help you create an easy and delicious meal for your next get-together when you serve a baked potato food bar with all the toppings!

hot to host a baked potato bar sign with a bunch of potatoes in the background

How To Plan A Baked Potato Food Bar

One of my favorite simple make-ahead party menus is to serve a baked potato bar. The best part is you can do all the prep work long before your party starts. This simple preparation and setup will allow you to enjoy the party and avoid the kitchen when guests arrive.

  1. Begin by planning what toppings you will serve. To make it easy, download my list of Baked Potato Bar Topping Ideas. Print the list and then check off the items you would like to serve. 
  2. After you decide what toppings you will serve, gather your recipes. Group the recipes in thoes that need to be cooked and the ones that do not. 
  3. Begin preparing your cooked toppings, such as chili, cheese sauces, meats, and veggies. 
  4. Next fill serving bowls with items that  do not required cooking suchs as cheese, chopped onions, sour cream an so forth. Be sure to cover the serving containgers with a thigh fitting lide and refrigerate. 
  5. Next, prep your potatoes for baking. If you are in a hurry you could also use my Crispy Skin Air Fryer Baked.

Free Printable To Help You Organize A Baked Potato Bar

a shopping check off list for baked potato toppings and buffet cards

Be sure to download your copy of my Baked Potato Bar Toppings Ideas grocery list. As a bonus, there are printable tent card labels you can print on white cardstock, cut out, and fold. This will make it easy for you to label all the items on your baked potato bar.

Free Potato Bar Party Printable

Subscribe to get your free printable and weekly recipe ideas.

Baked potato bar printable sheet of topping ideas and Buffet cards
    We respect your privacy. Unsubscribe at any time.

    How To Set Up a Baked Potato Bar

    1. Set up a table or counter space where guests can easily access the toppings and baked potatoes. Begin by providing large, sturdy plates.
    2. Place the baked potatoes in a large serving tray or basket at the beginning of the line.
    3. Arrange bowls filled with the toppings in an organized manner. I suggest keeping the items together in these 5 main categories:
    • Cheese and Dairy Toppings
    • Meat Toppings
    • Vegetable Toppings
    • Sauce and Condiment Toppings
    • Herb and Spice Toppings

    For smaller toppings such as onions, chives, or bacon bits, use small bowls like these 18 oz Disposable Plastic Salad Bowls with lids to put them in after prepping.

    For larger items like cheese or vegetables, use larger bowls such as 32 oz. Plastic Salad Bowls To-Go With Airtight Lids

    If you are serving warm toppings, then make them the day before and reheat them in a 3-Station 1.5-Quart Oval Slow Cooker Buffet.

    A fun way to serve guests their baked potatoes is in Premium Disposable Paper Food Serving Trays. They are large enough to hold a big potato and lots of toppings, up to 2.5 pounds worth. Also, it will be easy to clean up for you after the party is over.

    1. Be sure to provide serving utensils such as spoons or tongs for each topping.
    2. Consider labeling the toppings, especially if there are unique or unfamiliar options.  I have a free sheet of food bar labels you can print and label for your food bar.
    3. Keep the hot toppings warm using chafing dishes, slow cookers, or warming trays.
    4. At the end of the line, have napkins and silverware for your guest to take to their seats. 
    Perfect Air Fryer Baked Potatoes Recipe on a plate with parsely and butter

    How can I keep baked potatoes warm for a party?

    • Use a slow cooker: Place the baked potatoes in a slow cooker on the “warm” setting to maintain their temperature.
    • Wrap in foil and place in a cooler: Wrap the baked potatoes in foil and store them in a pre-warmed cooler to keep them insulated and warm.
    • Use a chafing dish: Transfer the baked potatoes to a chafing dish with a lid to keep them warm throughout the party.
    • Keep in the oven: If you’re serving the potatoes at home, you can keep them warm in the oven set to a low temperature, around 200°F.

    Baked Potato Veggie Topping Ideas

    Fresh Vegetables

    • Chopped green onions
    • Diced tomatoes
    • Sautéed mushrooms
    • Sliced bell peppers
    • Diced red onions
    • Chopped cilantro
    • Sliced jalapeños
    • Avocado slices
    • Shredded lettuce

    Cooked Vegetables

    • Sautéed spinach
    • Roasted bell peppers
    • Grilled zucchini
    • Caramelized onions
    • Crock Pot asparagus
    • Grilled corn
    • Roasted Brussels sprouts
    • Grilled eggplant
    Instant Pot Copycat LongHorn Steakhouse Broccoli Recipe
    How often have you boiled or steamed broccoli only to discover it's a mushy mess? With this easy LongHorn Steakhouse broccoli recipe, you'll learn the secret to how restaurants make perfect steamed broccoli so that it comes out with that tender-crisp texture you want your broccoli to have. Using just a handful of ingredients and a few simple steps, you can cook up a lemon butter drizzle the whole family will devour (you might need to make a double batch).
    Get Recipe
    Fresh, steamed broccoli drizzled with garlic herb butter sauce.

    Cheese and Dairy Toppings

    • Sour cream
    • Butter
    • Shredded cheddar cheese
    • Shredded mozzarella cheese
    • Grated parmesan cheese
    • Crumbled feta cheese Cream cheese
    • Cottage cheese
    • Grated Swiss cheese
    • Blue cheese crumbles
    • Pepper Jack chees
    • Colby Jack cheese
    Creamy Rotel Sausage Dip (Easy Crock Pot)
    This easy warm Rotel sausage dip recipe combines the classic flavors of sausage and Rotel tomatoes with creamy Velveeta and cream cheese for a sure party or game day hit.
    Get Recipe
    Rotel sausage dip next to chips and topped with cilantro and pickled jalapenos

    Sauces and More

    • Beer Chili
    • Ranch dressing
    • Pesto sauce
    • Alfredo sauce
    • Gravy
    • Chimichurri sauce
    • Hollandaise sauce
    Best Copycat Texas Roadhouse Chili Recipe
    If you want to serve thick Texas-style red chili, then you need to make the Best Texas Roadhouse Chili Recipe. It’s one of my reader's favorite recipes on Intentional Hospitality. They have tested it, and declare it's the best copycat Texas Roadhouse Chile you can make at home, hands down!
    Get Recipe
    a bowl of copycat recipe of texas roadhouse chili

    Herbs and Spices

    Sazon Seasoning
    Simple to make, Sazon Seasoning is a flavorful all-purpose blend of seasonings that accents Mexican, Cuban, and Spanish recipes for rice, beans, vegetables, and meat dishes.
    Get Recipe
    sazon seasoning in a bowl with a few fresh herbs and seeds scattered near it

    Meat Toppings

    • Sausage crumbles
    • Bacon 
    • Diced ham
    How To Cook Melt In The Mouth Roast Beef With Lots of Gravy
    Let me show you how to cook melt in the mouth roast beef using this Instant Pot Roast Beef and Gravy recipe. This roast beef recipe is a quick and easy dinner that creates a tender, delicious beef roast with plenty of gravy to top a side of mashed potatoes.
    Get Recipe
    close up of roast beef and a bowl of gravy
    Instant Pot Shredded Chicken Breast Recipe
    This 3-ingredient instant pot shredded chicken recipe is the simplest and most reliable way to cook up juicy, plump chicken that shreds up perfectly so you can use it to create a variety of delightful meals during the week.
    Get Recipe
    Shredded instant pot chicken recipe with forks to pull it apart on the table.
    Instant Pot Pulled BBQ Chicken Recipe
    This quick and delicious Instant Pot pulled BBQ chicken recipe is perfect for sandwiches, BBQ plates, or tacos in just 30 minutes.
    Get Recipe
    Instant Pot Pulled BBQ Chicken sandwich Recipe

    International Themed Baked Potato Topping Ideas

    Here is a fun and easy idea: create an international baked potato bar.

    Italian Baked Potato

    • Olives
    • Roasted garlic cloves
    • Diced tomatoes
    • Chopped basil & parsley
    • Parmesan cheese
    • Ricotta cheese
    • Pepperoni
    • Mozzarella cheese
    • Pesto sauce
    Turkey Bolognese Recipe
    This classic Italian turkey bolognese recipe makes a hearty sauce to serve up with your favorite pasta. Tomatoes are slow cooked with onions, garlic, celery, carrots and lots of fresh herbs for a pasta dinner eveyone will love!
    Get Recipe
    Turkey bolognese recipe on a plate with chili pepper seeds and parmesan in bowls by it.
    Sicilian Green Olives Recipe
    Bring a little Sicily to your table with this delicious marinated Sicilian Green Olives Recipe. The olives are infused with fresh herbs, garlic, dried oregano, a pinch of chili pepper for heat all smothered in extra virgin olive oil and white vinegar dressing.
    Get Recipe
    Green Marinated Sicilian Olives Recipe in a bowl

    Greek Potato

    • Sauteed onions
    • Spinach
    • Sauteed mushrooms
    • Greek seasoning
    • Feta cheese
    Creamy 2-Minute Yogurt Dill Dip Recipe
    Creamy Yogurt Dill Dip is an ideal quick party dip that only takes two minutes to prepare. With a blend of Greek yogurt, mayo, minced onion, garlic, and dill perfect with veggies and chips.
    Get Recipe
    Made with sour cream in a bowl with chips carrot sticks and celery sticks
    Herb Crusted Chicken
    This perfect copycat recipe for Texas Roadhouse Herb Crusted Chicken is so flavorful and cooks up juicy on the inside with a perfect seared herb crust on the outside. If you’re craving Texas Roadhouse chicken, this recipe teaches you the perfect combination of seasonings and a simple cooking technique to ensure your chicken is restaurant-quality, right in your own kitchen.
    Get Recipe
    Texas Roadhouse Herb Crusted Chicken Plate juicy drips

    BBQ Baked Potato

    The Secret To Making Tender BBQ Slow Cooker Pulled Pork
    Do you want to make your BBQ pork fall-off-the-bone tender? I'm going to teach you how to make super tender BBQ slow cooker pulled pork in under 10 minutes of prep to cooking time.
    Get Recipe
    Pulled pork that has had extra sauce added after it was shredded
    Best Homemade Slow Cooker Boston Baked Beans Recipe
    The best homemade slow cooker Boston baked beans are made with molasses, brown sugar, and plenty of chunks of bacon for an unforgettable flavor and perfect texture. Easily cooked in the Crock Pot, this easy recipe takes just 15 minutes to prepare and bubbles away all afternoon. Sweet, savory beans are easier than you thought, and come together perfectly every time.
    Get Recipe
    A big pot of Boston baked beans that are Saucy with big chunks of bacon and a spoon with beans on it ready to serve
    Bacon and Whiskey BBQ Sauce
    This is such a unique but oh so lip smacking good BBQ sauce that will please everyone. This sauce dances flavor on your tongue with sweet smoky bacon flavor and punches of whiskey, garlic and maple.
    Get Recipe
    Bacon Whiskey BBQ next to a bottle of Seagram's and a spoon on it that has been dipped into the sauce

    Mediterranean Baked Potato Ideas

    Roasted Red Pepper Spread
    Roasted Red Pepper Spread is a delightfully sweet, Mediterranean flavored roasted red pepper and tomato spread that can be used as a dip for naan bread, a sauce for pizza and pasta, or a sandwich spread.
    Get Recipe
    roasted red pepper spread

    Indian baked potato

    Indian Toor Dal Instant Pot Recipe With Rice
    Toor Dal Instant Pot Recip is an easy Indian recipe made with yellow split pigeon peas, aromatic spices all cooked in an Instant Pot pressure cooker. This Instant Pot method makes a quick and creamy dinner your whole family will enjoy, and you won't have to spend a lot of time in the kitchen.
    Get Recipe
    Indian Tor doll that was made in instant pot served in a bowl with Jasmine rice

    Thai Baked Potato

    • Sprinkle Thai Seasoning
    • Shredded coconut
    •  Tandoori chicken
    • Paneer (Indian cottage cheese)
    • Mint chutney-
    • Mango chutney
    • Spiced yogurt
    • Sliced green chilies
    • Diced red onions
    • Diced papaya
    • Diced mango
    Spicy Thai Chicken Recipe
    Grill up juicy Thai rubbed chicken breasts topped with a spicy sauce and shredded coconut in a matter of minutes for a delicious meal the whole family will love.
    Get Recipe
    Thai grilled chicken on a plate sprinkled with fresh herbs and toasted coconut

    Mexican Baked Potato Toppings

    Mexican Crockpot Chicken Tacos Recipe (5 Min. Prep)
    Spice up your taco dinner with this authentic Mexican crockpot chicken tacos recipe. With simple ingredients and minimal prep time, these tacos are not only delicious but also easy to prep in under 5 minutes. 
    Get Recipe
    A bowl of Crock-Pot chicken tacos sitting next to a taco shell stuffed with meat cheese and sour cream and a Sprinkle of salsa
    Seasoned Taco Meat Recipe For A Party: How Much Per Person
    If you are hosting a Mexican dinner party or taco bar, it's easy to figure out how much meat per person you will need for your party. This simple calculation sheet ensures that you don't run out of meat or end up wasting food. Note* One pound of hamburger yields 14 oz of cooked meat. This recipe figures 4 ounces of cooked meat per taco. ** Slid the servings on the recipe card for how many tacos you need to make then print your recipe.
    Get Recipe
    how much taco meat for a crowd in a bowl with taco seasoning next to the bowl.
    Mexican Cabbage Slaw Recipe With Zesty Dressing
    This authentic Mexican cabbage slaw recipe is complete with a zesty lime dressing for a fresh-tasting, brightly colored side dish that pops on any dinner table or potluck spread.
    Get Recipe
    mexican slaw with pieces of pineapple and cilantro mixed in
    Creamy Homemade Restaurant Style Queso Dip
    This creamy restaurant-style homemade queso dip recipe is a blend of gooey cheeses and Mexican seasonings with a punch of heat. It's the perfect dip with tortilla chips or any of your favorite Mexican foods.
    Get Recipe
    warm queso dip topped with jalapenos and cilantro
    5 Ingredient Crock Pot Chili Cheese Dip
    Spice up your party with this delicious and easy make-ahead 5 ingredient chili cheese dip! Perfect for game day or topping on baked potatoes and nachos.  This warm creamy cheese dip recipe is the perfect crowd-pleasing appetizer for which everyone will want the recipe. 
    Get Recipe
    warm chili cheese dip ready to serve with cilantro, jalapeno and onions on top

    Save For Later!